Stories
De-Rating Trap: Why Strong Earnings Don't Always Lead to Winning Stocks
M
Moneycontrol•21-09-2026, 05:01
De-Rating Trap: Why Strong Earnings Don't Always Lead to Winning Stocks
- •Carnelian Capital highlights that strong earnings growth doesn't guarantee strong stock returns, citing the 'de-rating trap' where valuation multiples decline.
- •An analysis of BSE 500 companies revealed 40% experienced de-rating between 2016-2026, with profits growing at 15% CAGR but market cap only 10% CAGR.
- •Examples like Aptus Value Housing Finance and HDFC Bank show companies with significant profit growth but negative stock returns due to high initial valuations.
- •Paying too much for expected growth, especially in mid- and small-cap stocks or popular themes, can lead to de-rating even with continued earnings growth.
- •The most damaging de-rating occurs when both valuations and earnings decline, triggered by factors like competitive dynamics, regulatory changes, or governance issues.
Key Questions Answered
Aptus Value Housing Finance experienced a profit growth at a 28% CAGR from 2021 to FY26, but its stock produced a negative 6% CAGR because investors had already priced in much of the expected growth when the company listed, leading to a valuation de-rating.
Carnelian analysed 272 BSE 500 companies with over 10 years of trading history and found that approximately 40%, or 110 companies, experienced a valuation de-rating of at least 5% between March 2016 and March 2026.
According to Carnelian, the more damaging form of de-rating occurs when valuations and earnings decline together due to four broad triggers: changing competitive dynamics, regulatory changes, governance concerns, and large acquisitions or capex commitments.
